San Antonio – Market Square is a hot spot in the Alamo City no matter what time of year it is. Here you can find all sorts of Mexican goods and Tex-Mex. Mi Tierra is the grandaddy of them all, sitting here since 1941. 40 years later, the same family behind this San Antonio staple opened up another eatery at the square; La Margarita. “The restaurant was like my playground when I was a kid,” said William Cortez. “Started working when I was 12.”
William is the great grandson of Pedro Cortez, the man who started this business all those years ago. He’s the oldest of the 4th generation of Corteze’s continuing this Alamo City institution. “I never got the chance to meet my great-grandfather, but a lot of his stories were passed through my grandfather and his brothers,” said William. “For me, it’s very important to keep that family legacy and tradition alive.”
La Margarita’s claim to fame is a big one. “La Margarita was the first restaurant in the United States to have the sizzling fajita,” said William.
Turns out William’s grandfather Jorge Cortez brought this idea back with him after a trip to Mexico. “He went traveling to Monterrey and Laredo,” said William. “And that’s where he discovered those fajitas. We’re definitely getting fajitas today.”
But it’s not all about the beef here. Unbeknownst to most patrons is the other part of the sign for La Margarita, which tells you that it’s also an oyster bar. “So it’s La Margarita restaurant and Oyster Bar,” said William. “The oysters are delicious. The most popular here is the fajitas and fresh oysters.”
Roberto Gonzalez is the head chef at La Margarita, and he wanted to get things cracking with a half dozen of their fresh gulf oysters. The pre-shucked oysters have to be served within an hour of opening and the presentation is garnished in greatness.
As for the fajitas, they’re marinated for days before hitting the grill. “The fajita is outside fajita, so it’s the best,” said Roberto. “The process is about two to three days, and it sits marinating and then on the third day is when they cook it for service. The secret of the fajita is hard fire and then put the slow fire.”
While the meat sizzles, Robert gets to work on the veggies. These veggies get sautéed in special sauce, as a coffee cup of tequila heats up on the grill to add some flames to the process down the line. As everything cooks, cast iron skillets are heating up to the side to get that classic sizzle when the fajitas are served. After Robert prepares the pound of protein it’s time to fiesta.
So here we have a little bit of surf and a little bit of turf, and we’re going to start with the surf because how often can you get oysters here in San Antonio, so they’re already shucked, ready to go. Pop it out, dive into that cocktail sauce. Oh yeah, Those are definitely some fresh Gulf oysters. “It’s kind of strange, but yeah, they’re great too,” said customer Carlos Tijerina. “They’re amazing. Just put that Tabasco sauce on them and they’re great. Little Lemon.”
From the sea to the land. After a few days of Fiesta, you’re going to want something with a little oomph to it, so fajitas might be the way to go. The pollo is first to hit the pallet, and it’s plump and juicy and cooked to perfection.
As for the fajita beef. That is just marinated marvelously, easy to chew, goes down nice, and it’s got that good bold Texas flavor that you like with your Tex-Mex. It’s awesome. “I like chicken, but beef is a specialty, I would say,” said Carlos’ son Carlos Jr. “Yeah, go for the beef fajitas.”
Now we get to put together a fajita taco, so I go with my usual accompaniment, a little bit of pico, some guac, throw in a couple of those onions, cooked in that tequila, and then put that salsa all over it because I’m definitely a salsa fanatic. “They’re outstanding,” said Carlos. “When they’re on point, they’re just amazing.”
An absolutely marvelous combination with a fresh tortilla and that perfectly marinated grilled up beef. That is an excellent fajita taco. “Taste and tenderness,” said Carlos Jr. “It’s really hard to get that consistently, and I’d say Margarita does a really good job of that.”
I just can’t get over the cooking of the beef and the chicken. The chicken is plump and juicy and has a great smoky flavor. The beef as well is cooked to perfection. The marination is fantastic, a great smoky flavor, and it just comes right apart. “San Antonio is known,” said Carlos. “South Texas is known for Tex-Mex food, and this is the place to come.”
Well, my whole life beef fajitas have been one of my favorite meals in the Lone star state and here at La Margarita, it holds true, making it well worth the top on The Texas Bucket List. “Drinks are flowing. The food is good, everything smells good,” said Carlos Jr. “You have your live music, so it is one of those places that you definitely want to go to and experience for sure.”