San Antonio – When it comes to places to stay in San Antonio, we’ve check into the Menger Hotel many times on The Texas Bucket List. This historic hotel is the perfect place rest your head by the Riverwalk thanks to its proximity to one of our state’s most hallowed sites, The Alamo. Built in 1859, the Menger Hotel itself is a hot spot for history buffs. But there’s also a bar inside the hotel that also brings those seeking to hear a story about the Spanish American War and a particular president. “It’s hard not to be in awe of this place and the history behind it,” said Angela Pena, who has been pouring libations and presenting the lore about this little bar since 2008. “This has definitely been a place where generations of families have come and enjoyed the space, and to hear some of their stories has been really, really cool.”
This public house was put together in 1887 and is a replica of the House of Lord’s Pub in England. “This bar came in, like I said, 1887, where Mrs. Menger had only paid $15,300 for the actual 50 room hotel,” said Pena. “All of this woodwork cost $63,000 when it came in 1887. So I think we looked it up and it’s the equivalent of $2.2 million up to date.”
That didn’t stop Carrie Nations, a radical member of the temperance movement, from taking a chunk out of the wood. “She, in particular, would go around bars with a hatchet and give a whole spill how we were all going to go to hell in handbasket,” said Pena. “And I’m the stealer of men’s souls apparently, so. Yeah.”
Originally the bar was in another part of the hotel, but it was carefully moved, piece by piece, to its new location in 1958 and set up exactly the same as it was. Countless people have come to this bar counter to order a cold beverage, but there’s one customer in particular that folks love to hear about. “Well, it’s definitely the Teddy Roosevelt influence,” said Pena. “I think sometimes people are so surprised to see that he was here.”
Hence the reason there’s giant moose in the room. “He’s a good listener,” said Pena. “If he ever starts talking back, call for help.”
The 26th President of the United States assumed the presidency at the young age of 42 and prior to that, he had a lifetime’s worth of experiences. Some of those moments in time were spent right here in this bar, recruiting fellas to come fight with him in a little group known as the Rough Riders. “Fort Sam Houston supplied the equipment that they took to the Spanish American War with them,” said Pena. “So that was this purpose here, and it was another stop to get a few more boys to sign on the dotted line. So, it was business.”
A picture behind the bar showcases a younger Roosevelt in his uniform, gathering his cavalry unit for the war effort. “This was actually here in San Antonio during the training,” said Pena. “Down on Roosevelt Street, there’s a Roosevelt Park, that’s actually where the training was set up. So this was there in 1898 before they left for Florida.”
Now one of the most popular things to see at the Menger Bar are a couple of holes in the wall. But these aren’t just any holes, they’re bullet holes. “This bullet hole story is supposed to be pretty much a marksman competition,” said Pena. “When Teddy was here, he wanted to see who was a good shot. One of it’s supposed to be Teddy’s and the other is supposed to be the recruits. They were trying to get closest to the mirror without shattering it, and the one on the left is definitely that.”
When people come to the Menger Bar to raise a glass to Teddy and the things he did as president, there’s one drink of choice. “Definitely the old-fashioned,” said Pena. “I’m glad that trend’s come back around because it’s easy to push something you enjoy.”
While Pena’s favorite part about her gig at the bar is her secondary role as historian, she also gets a lot of questions about the supernatural history of Menger Hotel. “Sometimes I’d rather focus on the history than the ghost,” said Pena. “So sometimes people ask ‘Oh, have you seen a ghost?’ It’s like, ‘No, no.’ But there’s 32 of them, of course. They’re here. I tell people, ‘If you believe in them, they’re definitely around. So take lots of pictures, maybe you’ll catch something.’”
People have seen some unexplainable things in the bar, especially in the loft. “I can say over all these years, I’ve had people bring me their photos and there’s definitely things that I’ve seen in those photos that you can’t really dispute,” said Pena. “Maybe you can, but they’re there. They’re here. I just come in, and you leave me alone, and I’ll leave you alone and we’re all good.”
Altogether, there’s something for everyone at the Menger Bar, whether you’re looking for a stiff drink, a supernatural encounter or a history lesson. “This is just a moment in time that everybody should take in,” said Pena. “To see a bar like this in its entirety post-prohibition is not usual. So stepping in, sometimes I think people are surprised at how beautiful the small space that this is.”